Elisha v Vision Australia Limited [2024] HCA 50
High Court of Australia
Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot, & Beech-Jones JJ
Damages - Vision terminated Elisha's employment for serious misconduct - Elisha sued in Victorian Supreme Court, claiming damages for psychiatric injury caused by Vision breaching employment contract or being negligent in its processes leading to termination - trial judge found Vision's disciplinary hearing was a sham and a disgrace, Elisha's termination was unfair, unjust, and wholly unreasonable, Vision had breached employment contract, and damages should be awarded for psychiatric injury - trial judge rejected negligence claim on basis Vision did not owe duty of care - Court of Appeal agreed Vision had breached contract, but set damages aside as (1) damages for psychiatric injury are not available for breach of contract other than as consequent to physical injury or where contract was to provide enjoyment and relaxation; and (2) psychiatric injury was too remote from the breach of contract in this case - Court of Appeal agreed Vision had not owed duty of care - Elisha granted special leave to appeal to High Court - held (by Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Gleeson, & Beech-Jones JJ, Jagot J agreeing for separate reasons and Steward J dissenting): the employment contract incorporated Vision's disciplinary policies - subject to the particular terms and context of any particular contract, damages for psychiatric injury can be available for breach of contractual terms regarding manner of dismissal - liability for psychiatric injury in this case was not too remote, particularly given the serious circumstances of breach - unnecessary to consider existence of duty of care - Steward J would have held that the psychiatric injury was too remote and that Vision owed no duty of care - Jagot J expressed her own reasons for agreeing with the conclusions of the majority - by majority, appeal allowed and trial judge's award of damages restored.
Elisha
High Court of Australia
Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot, & Beech-Jones JJ
Damages - Vision terminated Elisha's employment for serious misconduct - Elisha sued in Victorian Supreme Court, claiming damages for psychiatric injury caused by Vision breaching employment contract or being negligent in its processes leading to termination - trial judge found Vision's disciplinary hearing was a sham and a disgrace, Elisha's termination was unfair, unjust, and wholly unreasonable, Vision had breached employment contract, and damages should be awarded for psychiatric injury - trial judge rejected negligence claim on basis Vision did not owe duty of care - Court of Appeal agreed Vision had breached contract, but set damages aside as (1) damages for psychiatric injury are not available for breach of contract other than as consequent to physical injury or where contract was to provide enjoyment and relaxation; and (2) psychiatric injury was too remote from the breach of contract in this case - Court of Appeal agreed Vision had not owed duty of care - Elisha granted special leave to appeal to High Court - held (by Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Gleeson, & Beech-Jones JJ, Jagot J agreeing for separate reasons and Steward J dissenting): the employment contract incorporated Vision's disciplinary policies - subject to the particular terms and context of any particular contract, damages for psychiatric injury can be available for breach of contractual terms regarding manner of dismissal - liability for psychiatric injury in this case was not too remote, particularly given the serious circumstances of breach - unnecessary to consider existence of duty of care - Steward J would have held that the psychiatric injury was too remote and that Vision owed no duty of care - Jagot J expressed her own reasons for agreeing with the conclusions of the majority - by majority, appeal allowed and trial judge's award of damages restored.
Elisha