Cessnock City Council v 123 259 932 Pty Ltd [2024] HCA 17
High Court of Australia
Gageler CJ, Gordon, Edelman, Steward, Gleeson, Jagot, & Beech-Jones JJ
Contracts - Cessnock City Council owned Cessnock Airport and entered an agreement for the respondent to lease a prospective lot - Council was obliged to take all reasonable action to register a plan of subdivision by a certain date - in due course, Council was unwilling to spend the money to do this, and so breached the condition and repudiated the agreement - the respondent had spent almost $3.7million constructing a hangar in reliance on the agreement, which was now wasted - the respondent was unable to prove the profit it would have made had Council performed under the contract, given multiple uncertainties - the respondent claimed its wasted expenditure as damages - the NSW Supreme Court awarded only nominal damages - the NSW Court of Appeal allowed an appeal and awarded damages of almost $3.7million - Council was granted special leave to appeal to the High Court - held: there is only one measure of damages for a breach of contract, being a sum that places the plaintiff in the same situation as if the defendant had performed - the Court has rejected distinct "reliance" losses and "expectation" losses between which a plaintiff can elect - however, a plaintiff can recover expenditure reasonably incurred in reliance on a contract, to the extent that it would have been recovered had the defendant performed - the issue was the burden of proof - the plaintiff bears the legal onus to prove loss from a breach of contract - however, where a defendant's breach of contract has caused or increased uncertainty about what would have happened had the defendant performed, the common law will facilitate discharge of the plaintiff's burden by assuming in the plaintiff's favour that, had the defendant performed, the plaintiff would have recovered the expenditure reasonably incurred in reliance on the contract - the uncertainties that arose in this case from the Council's breach made proof of the respondent's loss very difficult - in the absence of further evidence, the facilitation principle treated the respondent as having established its loss in the amount of its reasonable expenditure incurred in reliance on the contract - Council would have had to have led substantial evidence as to the matters of uncertainty to establish that the respondent would not have recouped some or all of this expenditure had Council performed - appeal dismissed.
Cessnock City Council